Hi,
I've been troubleshooting unreliable DMR SMS delivery via BrandMeister with my openSPOT4 Pro for two days and would appreciate some insight, since I've run out of things I can test from my side.
Setup:
- openSPOT4 Pro, firmware v92 (built Jul 30 2026)
- Homebrew/MMDVM connector, tested on multiple BrandMeister masters: France/2081, France/2082, Germany/2621, Germany/2622
- AnyTone AT-D878UV, sitting on a repeater's frequency (not a hotspot), CPS SMS format: M-SMS
- BrandMeister SelfCare: Brand = Motorola, Text Capture tested both on and off
- No port forwarding / NAT configured (UDP outbound only) — tried adding a static NAT for UDP/62030 afterwards, no clear improvement observed
Symptom:
Using the web interface's "DMR SMS chat" (Send to: Network, Private call, tried ETSI/UDP/Try all formats), sending a private SMS to another ham's DMR ID:
- The device log shows the message being sent in blocks, then repeatedly "dmr-sms: sms send retry timeout", resending all blocks, and finally "dmr-sms: call timeout" / "call end" — reported as failed in the UI.
- However, my correspondent sometimes actually receives the SMS — sometimes multiple times (once received 4x), matching the number of retries in the log. So it looks like the message IS delivered, but the ACK never makes it back to the openSPOT, causing it to keep resending until it gives up and reports failure.
- This happens identically across all 4 masters tested (France and Germany), so it doesn't seem to be a single master's SMSC being down.
- The ECHO/CONFIG test commands to the SMSC service ID (x95, e.g. 208995/262995) never get a reply either, on any of the masters tested.
- Meanwhile Homebrew ping/pong keepalive is 100% healthy throughout — no connectivity issue there.
Questions:
- Is the SMS ACK packet loss (sent-but-reported-failed, sometimes duplicate delivery) a known reliability issue with the SMSC/private-call-SMS mechanism in general, or specific to something in my setup?
- Why would ECHO/CONFIG to the x995 SMSC service never get a reply on 4 different masters?
Happy to attach full device logs if useful. Thanks for any pointers.
73,
Philippe, F4IQP